Disrespect or Defamation: The Case of Saviour Chishimba

Filed under: Politics,Special Comments |

Chishimba

By Isaac Mwanza

I have watched time and again the video circulating on social media where UPP leader, Dr. Saviour Chishimba, attacks the morality and standing of President Lungu. Before I volunteer to offer my view on whether Dr. Chishimba defamed the President, I want to point a few legal authorities:

The Zambia Police, in its pursuit of political cases which it has been taking to court, should always bear in mind the leading case decided by the Supreme Court in 2008 of Attorney General v Roy Clarke.

The brief facts of this case were that Mr. Clarke, on 1 January, 2004, submitted a satirical article entitled Mfuwe, over his satirical writing in which he called the President and two minister’s names. Mr. Clarke referred to some government leaders as “Muwelewele”, long legged giraffe, red-lipped, long fingered baboons and knocking knees. The article was written in crude language tinged with his dislike for the President and the government and contained descriptions of the physical features of the characters the respondents was writing about and allegations of rigging of elections by the President and some ministers.

The Supreme Court having noted Mr. Clarke to have been an old man who has lived long in this country and married to a Zambian woman observed that “despite this long stay in Zambia and actually living and rearing a family with a Zambian woman, the respondent (Clarke) strikes us as eccentric old man, who does not, in the least, care about or reflect on, the effect of what he writes. The respondent is also an old man, who has insulated himself from the realities of the Zambian cultural environment and is impervious to the cultural values and norms of the Zambian people,…The respondent, despite his old age also appears to have warped ideas of the freedom of expression.”

Can this be the case of Dr. Saviour Chishimba?

In the 1973 US case of De Jonge v State of Oregon, the Federal Supreme Court of the United States said:

“The right to support or criticize governments and politicians is fundamental to the democratic way of life and the freedom of speech and expression and is one which cannot be denied without violating those fundamental principles of liberty and justice which lie at the base of civil and political institutions…

So what is the issue of Dr. Chishimba? Is it legally defamation or merely his disrespect for President Lungu?

Having watched and carefully listened to Saviour Chishimba clip, I don’t find defamation of the President but total disrespect for Edgar Chagwa Lungu. The UPP leader had a constitutional right to express how he views Mr. Edgar Lungu no matter how unpopular, obnoxious, distasteful or wrong, it is within the ambit of freedom of speech and expression, provided there is no advocacy of/or incitement to violence or other illegal conduct.

However, I totally find that kind of disrespect of President Lungu unZambian and uninspiring to young people who look forward to elderly people like Dr. Chishimba for inspiration. It doesn’t matter who says who says what Dr. Chishimba said, if it was said by President Lungu to any other leader, I would find those remarks disrespectful.

On the conduct of Roy Clarke, the Supreme Court had this to say: “In Zambia, one can criticize or poke fun at the head of state and government leaders or indeed elders but his must be done in felicitous language and not in the crude language the respondent used. We have no doubt that in every other country you cannot say and write things using words and expressions that are not in consonance with the cultural values and norms of the people of that country.”

I therefore think the Zambian Police must not be used to incarcerate people even in cases they know they may be bound to lose in court. That is called persecution. In the same vein, Dr. Chishimba and other opposition leaders must learn to show respect for the President and for each other. Again, I think this country needs dialogue between leaders where they can frankly discuss issues than issuing disparaging remarks against each other. Since he Church seem to have biased positions, its time for individuals and institutions such as ZCID to take the front seat and move this dialogue.

I want to end by reminding President Lungu’s supporters and investigative wings who may be tempted to pounce on Dr. Chishimba by borrowing the words of Supreme Court when it reaffirmed:

“And in this judgment, we re-affirm what we have said in the previous cases that freedom of expression is one of the strong attributes of a democratic society and that to the extent permitted by the Constitution itself, freedom of expression must be protected at all costs and that those who hold public offices must be prepared, to suffer, and be tolerant, of criticism.”

bottom

14 Responses to Disrespect or Defamation: The Case of Saviour Chishimba

  1. Satire is the spice that makes light of untasteful, unplayable behaviour that appeals to the artistic need to laugh at incorrigible leaders. Some, because what a satirical opinion is what exactly they are, take offence. How I miss Roy Clerk and Jowie Mwiinga.

    Child of the Sky
    July 11, 2017 at 12:48 am
    Reply

  2. Question is can Judiciary in its current state pass a landmark judgment as in the case of the people versus Kalaki

    Child of the Sky
    July 11, 2017 at 1:18 am
    Reply

  3. As if the PF would listen! Since when did the PF listen? Do they even uphold the Constitution if the President himself is in the forefront breaking or abrogating the Constitution? Maybe the President thinks that since the current constitution was signed by him, then he is above it. Kaya, it looks the Zambian Constitution is personal to holder.

    Mumbeti
    July 11, 2017 at 2:47 pm
    Reply

  4. Long legged girraff – Mundia Sikatana (Late); Red lips – Benny Tetamashimba (Late); Mewelewele – Levy Mwanawasa (Late) but freedom of expression stil lives on.

    Jerabo
    July 11, 2017 at 3:35 pm
    Reply

  5. Unless you guys have nothing better to do,IGNORE,some of these unproductive,retrogressive rantings and move on progressively with a nationalistic approach,forget about these tuma one man parties talking shops,we have huge insurmountable difficulties ahead of us and you waste time on the modern Chama Chakomboka’s(MHSRIP) of today,FTJ would even invite them to lunch,its called Democracy mwebantu,let the police deal with serious issues,like the spate of fires etc..

    The spectator
    July 11, 2017 at 5:54 pm
    Reply

  6. You have gone too much with this so called democracy and wrong presidencies. No politician shall rule without having fear of GOD.

    AEC
    July 11, 2017 at 7:41 pm
    Reply

  7. Hello, I would like to subscribe for this webpage to get newest updates, so where can i
    do it please assist.

    zapyaforpc.me
    July 14, 2017 at 8:53 am
    Reply

  8. Hi, all the time i used to check blog posts here early in the morning, since i enjoy
    to find out more and more.

    Clemente Pratt
    July 14, 2017 at 4:01 pm
    Reply

  9. This Man is not inspiring and certainly not a presidential material. Chipimo is far much better and a mature leader than this f00l.

    True intellectuals don’t discuss personalities, they articulate issues. This generation needs issue based politics. Just arrest him, he went too far.

    Shaka
    July 16, 2017 at 11:57 pm
    Reply

  10. It is neither but treason if it is a Tonga who said that.

    Frank
    July 17, 2017 at 7:45 am
    Reply

  11. If you are going for best contents like me, simply visit this web page daily for the reason that it presents feature contents, thanks

    www.kamkibate.com
    July 17, 2017 at 7:33 pm
    Reply

  12. Hey terrific blog! Does running a blog like this take a lot of work?
    I have very little understanding of programming however I was hoping to start my own blog soon. Anyhow,
    if you have any ideas or tips for new blog owners please share.
    I know this is off topic nevertheless I just had to ask.
    Cheers!

    sbionline
    July 19, 2017 at 11:42 am
    Reply

  13. Magufuli recently reminded Tanzanians that freedom of expression has limits. There must be a tick line between freedom of expression and freedom of stupidity. So, Isaac Mwanza – how are you going to draw the distinction between inflammatory satirical language and inciting?

    OneNation
    July 20, 2017 at 7:44 pm
    Reply

  14. Thanks for finally writing about >Disrespect or Defamation: The Case of Saviour Chishimba | Zambian Eye <Liked it!

    phones
    August 19, 2017 at 12:38 pm
    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *